Menu
×
West Ashley Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 766-6635
Main Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 805-6930
Wando Mount Pleasant Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 805-6888
McClellanville Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 887-3699
Folly Beach Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 588-2001
Miss Jane's Building (Edisto Library Temporary Location)
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 869-2355
John L. Dart Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 722-7550
St. Paul's/Hollywood Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 889-3300
Mt. Pleasant Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 849-6161
Dorchester Road Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 552-6466
Edgar Allan Poe/Sullivan's Island Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 883-3914
John's Island Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 559-1945
Otranto Road Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 572-4094
Hurd/St. Andrews Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 766-2546
Baxter-Patrick James Island
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 795-6679
Bees Ferry West Ashley Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 805-6892
Village Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 884-9741
Keith Summey North Charleston Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 744-2489
Mobile Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 805-6909
Today's Hours
West Ashley Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 766-6635
Main Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 805-6930
Wando Mount Pleasant Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 805-6888
McClellanville Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 887-3699
Folly Beach Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 588-2001
Miss Jane's Building (Edisto Library Temporary Location)
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 869-2355
John L. Dart Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 722-7550
St. Paul's/Hollywood Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 889-3300
Mt. Pleasant Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 849-6161
Dorchester Road Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 552-6466
Edgar Allan Poe/Sullivan's Island Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 883-3914
John's Island Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 559-1945
Otranto Road Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 572-4094
Hurd/St. Andrews Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 766-2546
Baxter-Patrick James Island
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 795-6679
Bees Ferry West Ashley Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 805-6892
Village Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 884-9741
Keith Summey North Charleston Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 744-2489
Mobile Library
Closed (2024 - Independence Day)
Phone: (843) 805-6909
Patron Login
menu
Item request has been placed!
×
Item request cannot be made.
×
![loading](/sites/all/modules/hf_eds/images/loading.gif)
Does the Identity Objection to the future‐like‐ours argument succeed?
Item request has been placed!
×
Item request cannot be made.
×
![loading](/sites/all/modules/hf_eds/images/loading.gif)
- Author(s): Blackshaw, Bruce P.
- Source:
Bioethics. Feb2020, Vol. 34 Issue 2, p203-206. 4p. - Source:
- Additional Information
- Subject Terms:
- Abstract: Eric Vogelstein has defended Don Marquis' 'future‐like‐ours' argument for the immorality of abortion against what is known as the Identity Objection, which contends that for a fetus to have a future like ours, it must be numerically identical to an entity like us that possesses valuable experiences some time in the future. On psychological accounts of personal identity, there is no identity relationship between the fetus and the entity with valuable experiences that it will become. Vogelstein maintains that a non‐sentient fetus nonetheless has a future like ours because it is numerically identical with a future organism that has a mind that bears valuable experiences. Skott Brill, drawing on Jeff McMahan's embodied mind account, denies that human organisms directly have experiences, claiming that they only have experiences derivatively by virtue of their thinking part, and the loss of a future like ours is not transferred to the organism. I show that on McMahan's account, a strong case can be made for the organism having experiences directly, and the subject having these experiences derivatively. This negates Brill's reasoning, although it does imply that non‐sentient fetuses do not have a future like ours in quite the same way as we do. I conclude that this is not problematic for Marquis' argument. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
Contact CCPL
Copyright 2022 Charleston County Public Library Powered By EBSCO Stacks 3.3.0 [350.3] | Staff Login
No Comments.